Monday, May 08, 2006

Quarterback progress

I tend to be something of a Dana Bible apologist. While I don’t think he is a genius or great offensive coordinator, I don’t think he is nearly as bad as most BC fans believe. However, one of the criticisms that I’ve thought was valid is that under Bible QBs seem to regress. Worried that Matt Ryan might be the latest to slump, I looked back at the year to year progress of our past Bible signal callers. I was surprised by what I found. (Don’t you hate when statistics get in the way of popularly held beliefs?) While Brian St. Pierre’s Senior Year will remain the prototype for Senior Year regression, others have shown progress. Even Porter and St. Pierre’s rough final seasons showed improvement in some key stats. In fairness, statistics don’t tell the whole story. When I think of St. Pierre’s 2002, I don’t think about his improved completion percentage. Instead I think about a Senior QB with all the time in the world bouncing a throw at his wide-open Tight End’s feet against Pitt (BC lost). I don't think freezing up is a Bible issue. With St. Pierre and Porter, I just don’t think either were very good college QBs. The fact that we invested so much in them or started them over other guys may speak to bigger issues with Bible (and TOB), but I don’t think it is an indictment of Bible’s quarterback coaching or play calling.

Here are the numbers.

2001St. Pierre27914953.42,01613.52510
2002St. Pierre40723758.22,98312.61817
**Hasselbeck only played one year under Bible. I included him to see if he got better or worse with the new coach. He sort of stayed the same

The only recurring theme that did disturb me was yards per completion. It seems like every QB that spent at least two seasons as a starter saw his yards per completion decline in the second year. This might support the belief that Bible pushes checkdowns and short passes. I hope not. Matt Ryan’s downfield throws were things of beauty and really sparked the team and offense last season. Taking that aspect of his game away will help no one this year.

I'll keep trying to find a good forecast for what we can expect from Ryan. This little project made me feel better about my optimism since I can now say the second year slump is a player issue, not a Bible issue.


BCMike said...

I can honestly say that I think Ryan is the best QB we've had in quite some time. I was never sold on Porter, and thought that St. Pierre wasn't much better. I was pleasantly (I think we all were) with the Flutie-like play of Peterson; but alas, that was but one year (and the first of two bowl wins by Ryan).

The Hasselbecks were certainly respectable in college, but I think we can all agree that Matt's success has been greater in the NFL than it ever was at the heights.

I'm just saying that we're looking at a kid that has a honest-to-god realistic shot to win four bowl games---which is really pretty rare when you think about it. He's a smart kid with a very good arm who is making better and better throws. My only true concern in the lack of WR talent surrounding him.

I'm expecting very big things from Matt Ryan this year, and truly am not expecting to be disappointed.

Unknown said...

I really like your writing style. Such a nice Post, Can’t wait for the next one.

Asus - 14" Laptop - 4GB Memory - 320GB Hard Drive - Matte Deep Blue Square

Asus - 15.6" Laptop - 4GB Memory - 320GB Hard Drive - Black (X54C-BBK15)